Man Threatens to Stop Paying His Parents’ Mortgage and Bills If They Keep Letting His Sister Live Rent-Free

A man turned to the Reddit community for support after finding himself at odds with his parents over what he felt was an unfair family dynamic.

He explained in his post that while he had always been willing to help his parents financially, he began questioning whether his assistance was actually fueling what he described as his younger sister’s “pseudo free ride.”

His sister, he said, had “a decent job,” yet at 26 still lived at their parents’ home without helping them financially. “Why pay rent, food, utilities etcetera when you can get it for free,” he wrote, adding that she regularly bragged about how much she was saving by staying there.

She was even “currently on a vacation with friends in Japan,” something he noted she could easily afford thanks to the responsibilities their parents absorbed.

The tension reached a breaking point when he confronted his parents about the situation. “I recently told my parents they need to give her the boot and let her be an adult or I will stop helping them out with their expenses,” he explained.

He said he didn’t resent helping his parents, because “our parents did good by us,” but he struggled with the fact that his money was indirectly supporting his sister’s lifestyle. “I don’t feel right giving my sister a pseudo free ride,” he wrote. “She brags how she is ahead of the game for retirement and stuff.”

His sister’s carefree attitude only deepened his frustration. “I told her of course she is, all her major expenses are covered by someone else,” he added. According to him, their parents brushed off his concerns, insisting that it was “a lot harder for my sister’s age group.” He pushed back, reminding them, “It was hard for me also, but I had to make it work.”

A decade older than his sister, he acknowledged that his experience growing up was different from hers, but the disparity in treatment still stung. “Maybe an aspect of jealousy is present because living at home was never an option for me,” he reflected.

He shared that for his sister, staying at home “was just assumed,” but for him, independence had been mandatory. He recalled that academic achievements were treated differently as well. “I graduate with honors and get a card with 50 bucks,” he wrote. “She graduates it is a major milestone and family event.”

Beyond emotional hurt, he also emphasized the financial reality: his parents couldn’t afford to let his sister live rent-free without his support. “I pay their mortgage, insurance, and property taxes,” he said, underscoring that his contributions kept the household afloat.

That made his parents’ next suggestion especially shocking. “They suggested I use that money to help my sister instead so she can move out,” he wrote. His disbelief was clear. “WTF, she can afford to fly and stay in Japan for one month, she goes on multiple vacations a year and she needs help paying for rent?”

He did recognize that his parents’ concerns for his sister came from a real place. “I get they are worried about her mental health,” he said, noting she had a history of shutting down emotionally and once struggled with “self medicating” in high school. He didn’t dismiss their fear but still wondered if protecting her was keeping her from growing up.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

The man questioned whether his stance made him the villain in the story. “Maybe I am just being the jealous older sibling because I did not get the same type of love and care she did,” he admitted.

He explained that he had always been considered “old reliable,” while his sister’s achievements were treated as monumental. As he put it, “Though yeah, am I being an a—— here not taking into account my sister’s and her generation’s issues and hardships?”

His father told him he should help simply because “it is the right thing to do,” but the man remained torn, asking Reddit whether he was being “petty” for drawing a line.

Reddit commenters didn’t hesitate to weigh in. One user told him bluntly, “You ARE basically just paying your sister’s bills. Pull back all money.”

Another agreed, adding that if his parents wanted help with the mortgage, “they deed entirely to you. Then sis can learn about adulting by paying you rent or she can hit the bricks.”